By PHIL HATCHER
As a former union member (UNH AAUP), I was dismayed to read the recent Op Ed in support of the re-election of Secretary of State David Scanlan, which was written by Rich Gulla, the president of the State Employees’ Association of New Hampshire.
Mr. Gulla’s piece is centered on Secretary Scanlan’s actions with regard to the Trump administration’s threats and demands concerning the state’s confidential voter data. And Mr. Scanlan does deserve credit for standing up to this pressure. But, how much credit?
The demand for the voter data was legally absurd on its face, and Secretary Scanlan correctly stated that to release the data would violate state law. Praising an official for following state law seems to be a very low bar indeed.
What is more telling is how Secretary Scanlan responded to the bullying by state legislators pandering to the election security crowd in their base. He tried to nip this in the bud by empowering a special committee to study voter confidence. When the committee concluded that there was no evidence of widespread voting fraud in NH, the election deniers were not impressed. The legislature went on to pass a series of bills to address the non-existing problem of voter fraud and Secretary Scanlan simply caved to their pressure.
He surely knew that HB 1569, which eliminated the use of affidavits for voting, was unjustified (since there is no significant voter fraud), would unnecessarily erode voting rights in the state and would result in expensive litigation. But he meekly submitted to the legislature, simply saying he would do his best to implement it. And, of course, hundreds of people have been documented by nonpartisan observers as having been unnecessarily turned away at the polls and a federal judge has found pieces of the bill to be unconstitutional.
Worse yet is his response to HB 323, which aimed to eliminate the use of student IDs for voting. Again he knew this bill was unjustified, would unnecessarily make it harder for students to vote and would result in litigation. This time he not only meekly submitted, but then tried to fix a flawed bill by issuing guidance to voters and election officials that a federal judge found went beyond what HB 323 stated. Secretary Scanlan said that the order, issued by an experienced judge appointed by a Republican president, defied common sense. I recommend reading the order yourself. It paints a very damning picture of Secretary Scanlan’s actions to implement HB 323, as well as the State’s attempt to defend his actions. (And, no, the U.S. Supreme Court did not overturn the judge’s order. The Court simply said the order had been issued too close to the upcoming November 3 election and did not opine on the legal correctness of the order.)
The citizens of NH deserve a secretary of state who will see the voters of the state as his or her key constituency and who will resist unjustified attacks on voting rights by legislators pandering to their base. After all, all of our other rights rest on our voting rights. In particular, I would like to remind Mr. Gulla that workers’ rights depend on our voting rights.
Phil Hatcher is retired from the UNH faculty and currently serves as the moderator for Dover Ward 3.