Blowin’ in the Wind: Ayotte Rolls the Dice, Gambling Salvages Budget

MICHAEL KITCH

Share this story:

Blowin’ in the Wind is a new column by Michael Kitch. He has been writing in New Hampshire since 1982, sandwiching stints with either NH Times, NH Business Review and Laconia Daily Sun around spells within corporate communications and on the staff of the state Senate.

By MICHAEL KITCH, Blowin’ in the Wind

While campaigning for Governor, Kelly Ayotte often spoke of following “the Sununu path,” only to find that it meandered into a fiscal quagmire that would lead her to forsake her long held aversion to expanding gambling to salvage her budget from the quandary unwittingly triggered by her predecessor.

A decade ago, Gov. Maggie Hassan vetoed the budget crafted by Republican lawmakers that reduced the rates of both the Business Profits Tax (BPT) and Business Enterprise Tax (BET), which together amount to more than a third of state tax revenue. She warned that lowering the tax rates would sap revenues and throw the budget out of balance. Prodded by then Executive Councilor Chris Sununu, the Republican legislature overrode the veto.

When Sununu became governor in 2016, Republican lawmakers went on a tax trimming spree, reducing the rates of the Business Profits Tax (BPT) and Business Enterprise Tax (BET) rates in 2016, 2018, 2019, 2022 and 2023. In 2019 Sununu vetoed a budget rescinding the tax cuts. Reprising the siren song of the disciples of supply-side economics, lawmakers believed lower taxes would spur the pace of business expansion and economic growth, which in turn would increase business tax revenues and more than pay for themselves. 

Meanwhile, in 2021 Republican lawmakers compounded the fiscal challenge by reducing then repealing the Interest and Dividends Tax, which raised $147.3 million in FY 2023 and $184.3 million in FY 2024 before its repeal this year and also reduced the Meals and Rooms Tax.

An analysis by Phil Sletten of the NH Fiscal Policy Institute exposed the folly of this strategy. He calculated that while business tax revenues grew modestly between FYs 2015 and 2024, had the rates not been reduced the BPT and BET alone would have returned between $795 million and $1.17 billion more revenue than was collected. He found no evidence that reducing these tax rates fostered economic growth or increased revenue.

Instead, Sletten concluded that rising corporate profits, not lower tax rates, increased corporate tax revenue and that by lowering its tax rates, New Hampshire forsook a large share of it.  Between 2015 and 2024 corporate profits rose 76 percent nationwide while corporate tax revenues rose 192 percent. In the five New England states, excluding New Hampshire, corporate tax revenue grew 172 percent, but rose just 124 percent in New Hampshire, indicating that tax policy shrunk rather swelled revenues.

Meanwhile, in 2021 Republican lawmakers compounded the fiscal challenge by first reducing then repealing the Interest and Dividends Tax, which raised $147.3 million in FY 2023 and $184.3 million in FY 2024 before its repeal this year while also reducing the Meals and Rentals Tax, another major revenue source.

For six of the past seven months business tax revenues have trailed both projected and prior year returns. As FY 2025 drew to a close business tax revenues had fallen $161.4 million short of plan and $130.8 million short of the prior year.

With Sununu distracted by political punditry and presidential politics a raft of homegrown Tea Partiers and migrating Free Staters grasped control the Republican majority in the House and strengthened their presence in the Senate. These lawmakers, many outright Libertarians, aligned with the Liberty Alliance and House Freedom Caucus, aimed to shrink government by starving it of revenue.

In February, Gov. Ayotte presented her budget of $16 billion, increasing the current budget by $8 million, which would fund most departments and agencies at or near current levels. Significant appropriations included $32.9 million to raise retirement benefits for some police officers and firefighters, $32 million for Special Education Aid and $73.5 million to fund universal eligibility for the Education Freedom Account program.

Ayotte’s budget hinged on projecting that slumping business tax revenues and the repeal of the Interest and Dividends Tax would be overcome by rebounding returns from the BPT and BET. She also proposed hiking the estimated revenue from the Meals and Rentals tax and Real Estate Transfer taxes and, most significantly, introducing video lottery terminals at licensed charitable casinos. 

Projecting a revenue shortfall of $513.5 million, the House took a cleaver to the Governor’s budget, and shrunk it to $15.5 million. Cuts included reductions to Medicaid reimbursements, developmental services, community mental health services and the University System of New Hampshire. The House also eliminated 326 positions and four agencies while directing departments and agencies to reduce expenses by $95.5 million, with nearly half the cuts falling on the Department of Health and Human Services. The House sought to wring revenue from some 90 fees for licenses and permits.

“This budget puts the New Hampshire taxpayers first,” House Majority Leader Jason Osborne told his members, “and not the bureaucracies that have ballooned and bloated since 2020.”

The Senate set about restoring most but not all the cuts to the Governor’s budget made by the House. Shortly after hearing the bleak revenue forecast from Lindsey Stepp, Commissioner of Revenue Administration, in early June the Senate voted a $15.9 billion budget, closely matching the Governor’s proposal. Then the Senate drew on more timely revenue data and increased revenue estimates to fund its budget. 

After meeting again with Stepp, Sen. Tim Lang, who chairs the Senate Ways and Means Committee, and his counterpart in the House Representative John Janigian agreed to boost projected combined business tax revenue to $1.2 billion in FY 2026 and FY 2027. Insurance Commissioner D.J. Bettencourt had informed the Senate that growing concentration in the insurance market was increasing the cost of premiums. Consequently, he projected revenue from the Insurance Premium Tax to increase by $15 million in the coming biennium.

But the Lottery hit the jackpot. With the introduction of Keno in 2018, the internet-based lottery in 2019, sports betting in 2020 gambling revenues were on a roll already then the Lottery added $50 scratch tickets and removed the cap on bets at table games. Gambling had become the fastest growing source of state revenue. When Ayotte indicated she was open to video lottery terminals — slot machines — the horse left the barn.

Between February and June, Charlie McIntyre, executive director of the NH Lottery Commission, ratcheted up his revenue estimates at least three times. After expecting to close this year with $190 million he bumped that number to $207 million and conservatively projected $200 million in each year of the next biennium. Then, after learning that the number of video lottery terminals at major casinos in Nashua, Salem and Seabrook were expected to nearly double he expected to rake in $221.5 million in FY 2026 and $236.7 million in 2027.

The Committee of Conference convened to reconcile the differences between the House and Senate budgets including only one Democrat, leaving House and Senate Republicans to haggle among themselves, mostly behind closed doors, to strike a bargain.

The committee reversed and restored the $52.5 million cut to reimburse Medicaid service providers, the $37.8 million cut to community mental health and developmental services, and the $18.8 million cut to services for the developmentally disabled. The budget restores more than 100 jobs at the Department of Corrections, eliminated by the House, while ordering the department to trim expenses by $10 million. While funding for the University System of New Hampshire is set to shrink year-over-year, the $85 million appropriation reverses the $50 million cut proposed by the House.

However, no sooner had the conference committee signed off on its $15.7 million budget, than the Governor threatened to veto it, citing two issues in particular. Lawmakers amended her plan to apply $27.5 million a year for decade to restore benefits for some 1,500 active police officers, firefighters and corrections officers hired before 2011 when benefits were reduced. She also took issue with a change in the formula for distributing state aid to public schools, which would reduce funding to Manchester, easily the largest school district, by $10.2 million.

On Thursday the Legislature will put the budget to a vote with the outcome in question. Many Republicans, especially in the House, believe it spends too much, the Democrats don’t like it at all and the Governor has cast a shadow over the proceedings.

 Whatever the outcome this budget will be marked by the expansion of gambling, which after years of intense lobbying and heated debate has at last become a sheet anchor of future budgets. With this budget, the take from the Lottery and Gaming Commission has become the fastest growing and third largest source of state revenue topped only by the combined business taxes and Meals and Rental Tax.

Ironically Ayotte, a critic and opponent of gambling throughout her career, will be remembered as the Governor who finally brought slot machines to New Hampshire, but she might not have found herself pressed to do so but for the missteps taken by her predecessor along the “Sununu path.”

Comments are closed.