Blowin’ in the Wind is a new column by Michael Kitch. He has been writing in New Hampshire since 1982, sandwiching stints with either NH Times, NH Business Review and Laconia Daily Sun around spells within corporate communications and on the staff of the state Senate.
By MICHAEL KITCH, Blowin’ in the Wind
In the 2018 election the Democrats won majorities in the New Hampshire House and Senate for the first time in nearly a decade and for only the fifth time since Franklin Pierce was elected President in 1853. Two years later the majorities were erased.
After the 2020 election the party convened the Blue NH Task Force to conduct a postmortem of the loss at the polls. “In 2020 NH Democrats had no compelling message,” the report read. Two years later the Republicans held their majorities and again the task force stressed that “Messaging needs to be a top priority of the NHDP.” In particular, the report noted the party was “consistently branded as having no response to high taxes.”
Still, with the 2024 election a year away the report closed on a high note. “There are no signs of the two-decade long trend of New Hampshire turning blue slowing down,” the report declared. “NH Democrats enter another presidential election cycle in excellent position to win at every level of the ballot.”
Instead, in 2024 Republicans again won the governorship, four of five seats on the Executive Council and increased their majorities in the House and Senate. The GOP has carried the House, Senate and Executive Council in four of the last five elections cycles. At the same time, Democratic candidates for federal offices — President, US Senate and US House — carried the state in every race.
Since the 1990s the dynamics of state politics have been overshadowed by the outcome of the Claremont litigation that successfully challenged the system of funding public schools almost exclusively with local property taxes. As a result, the differences in property wealth among cities and towns have manifest themselves in inequitable educational opportunities for school children and inequitable tax liabilities for property taxpayers.
In 1997 the NH Supreme Court ruled in the Claremont cases that the state must fund a public education for every child with taxes “equal in valuation and uniform in rate” across the state. This decision did not require increasing spending for public schools. Only a handful of states spend more per pupil than New Hampshire.
Instead, the decision required a change to the tax structure that would provide equitable opportunities for children and ensure equitable treatment of taxpayers, which at once raised the specter of an income tax, “the third rail” of New Hampshire politics.
Ever since the leadership of the NHDP has treated advocacy for an income tax as a heresy to be exorcised rather than a policy to be considered, not least to afford political cover for Democrats seeking or holding federal office. The party’s fiscal policy is but a silent echo of the mantra of the GOP.
Democratic Governor Jeanne Shaheen, who enjoyed approval ratings of 70 percent, proposed several plans to address the court’s order, none of which complied with it, and scuttled a bipartisan income tax bill. John Lynch, her equally popular successor, in league with Republican lawyers and politicians, fruitlessly pursued constitutional amendments to rid the Constitution of the Claremont precedents altogether.
In 2020, when Democrats held majorities in the House and Senate, they formed a Commission to Study School Funding and appropriated $500,000 to engage a consultant to shepherd its work. At the outset the Commission ruled out consideration of an income tax as a means of funding its recommendations, prompting the Commissioner of Revenue Administration to question the decision and ultimately forego the proceedings.
The Commission drew up a plan funded primarily by property taxes and featuring targeted aid to the neediest districts, which perpetuated disparate tax rates it claimed would be “acceptable.” The Commission’s work informed legislation introduced in 2021, 2023 and 2025, which failed to reach the House floor.
The fallout from the 2024 election roiled the ranks of the NHDP. In January, as the party prepared to elect its officers, nine of the ten County Chairs presented a memorandum to the Executive Committee expressing concerns about the “performance, governance and transparency” of the party. Their memorandum raised a number of organizational and operational issues without addressing the party’s message twice highlighted by its task force.
Mat Stover, chair of the Rockingham County Democratic Committee, with endorsements from his fellow county chairs, mounted a campaign to deprive Ray Buckley of a tenth term as party chair. In his pitch, Stover said that a decade of “underperformance has lost the trust of every constituency we need to succeed — voters, volunteers, candidates and donors.” Donors, he said, “have closed their checkbooks to the NHDP” while Democrats now represent the smallest share of registered voters since 2007.
Stover, a financier in the mode of John Lynch, touted his experience in the business world and, in the tone of a corporate prospectus echoed calls for organizational and operational changes to bring about a “turnaround” in the party’s fortunes. But, he made no mention of the party’s lack of a persuasive message. Buckley, with the support of the party’s old guard, was re-elected by a comfortable margin.
Whatever shortcomings in the governance, organization and machinery of the party have contributed to its electoral performance, voters hear and respond only to its message while the NHDP has offered only “sounds of silence,” which have carried a high price.
In 2024 the Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee had designated New Hampshire a “battleground state,” counting it among five states where Democrats were expected to flip Republican legislative majorities and invested more than $1 million in the campaign. In the wake of the election results the DLCC downgraded New Hampshire to among three states where Democrats were not expected to recapture the House until 2030 when a majority in the Senate would still remain out of reach.
Since gaining control of the Legislature the Republicans have aggressively trimmed state taxes, which by shrinking state revenues has led to budget cuts that threaten to erode the quality of public services while downshifting costs to municipalities where they will add to the burden of property taxpayers. At the same time, the Republicans have equally aggressively invested public funds, much of them raised from property taxpayers, to subsidize and expand enrollment in private and parochial schools.
School funding and equitable taxation are constitutional rights and two sides of the same coin. One is an investment in our children’s future and the other is an assurance of fiscal justice for taxpayers. Property tax burdens vary from one municipality to another and with them the quality of the educational opportunities they provide for their children. Moreover, property taxes are not only inequitable but also regressive. The one-fifth of households earning less than $35,000 pay 6 percent of their income in property tax while the one percent with incomes exceeding $721,000 pay two percent.
In the face of these inequities the NHDP remains tongue tied. The party platform reads, “We respect both the will of the people and the constitutional requirement of fair and equal taxation.” Mere words and empty ones.