Op-Ed: Tax Cuts Are Not the Same as Good Government

Courtesy photo

George Bald

Share this story:

By GEORGE BALD

A recent op-ed by a Republican state representative celebrated New Hampshire’s record of cutting taxes as though cutting a tax is, by definition, an accomplishment.

But before celebrating any tax cut, we should ask a more important question: What are we getting in return, and what are we giving up?

There is nothing inherently wrong with cutting taxes. When the government is collecting more than it needs, when a tax discourages economic growth, or when it places an unnecessary burden on working families, reducing it can make good economic sense.

But taxes are not simply money taken away from people. They are also how we pay for the things we collectively expect the government to provide: good schools, safe communities, roads and bridges, addiction treatment, and programs that help working families participate in the economy.

New Hampshire has aggressively pursued tax reductions. Business tax rates have been reduced repeatedly, and the Interest and Dividends Tax was repealed for tax periods beginning January 1, 2025.  the NH Fiscal Policy Institute estimates that reductions in the state’s two primary business tax rates and repeal of the Interest and Dividends Tax reduced state revenue by $500 million to $800 million during the current budget cycle. 

Those policies may make attractive political talking points. But tax cuts should not be considered in isolation from what is happening to New Hampshire families.

Consider education.

In 2022, New Hampshire ranked last among all 50 states in the percentage of public K-12 school revenue coming from state funds. Meanwhile, locally raised property taxes accounted for 61 percent of school district revenue in the 2023-24 school year. [nhfpi.org]

So we should ask: Is cutting a state tax really a victory if communities must make up the difference through property taxes?

Then there is child care.

For families with young children, affordable child care isn’t a luxury. It can determine whether a parent or caregiver can work. Yet the average price of center-based care for an infant and a four-year-old increased about 32 percent between 2017 and 2025, while the number of licensed providers declined by 120 programs. 

This isn’t only a family issue. It is an economic issue. Child care shortages cost New Hampshire businesses an estimated $38 million to $59 million in lost revenue in 2025 because of reduced productivity and workforce disruptions. 

If we are serious about helping New Hampshire businesses, shouldn’t we measure that economic loss alongside the savings from cutting taxes?

Housing presents an equally serious challenge. Between 2015 and 2025, the median sale price of a single-family home in New Hampshire increased 114 percent. When mortgage rates, property taxes and a 5 percent down payment are included, the estimated monthly cost of purchasing that median-priced home climbed from about $1,500 to roughly $3,900. 

And then there is addiction.

New Hampshire has made real progress in reducing drug-related deaths, and that progress deserves recognition. But the problem is hardly behind us. In 2024, 287 Granite Staters died from drug-related causes, and opioids were involved in 83.6 percent of those deaths. Even more troubling, nearly three out of four New Hampshire adults who needed substance-use-disorder treatment in 2022-23 did not receive it. 

Investment matters here. Since 2014, New Hampshire has invested more than $834 million in substance-use-disorder prevention, treatment and recovery services. The decline in drug-related deaths is a reminder that government spending should not automatically be viewed as a failure. Sometimes public investment produces exactly the kind of results we want the government to achieve. 

The same principle applies to economic development.

Business tax rates matter. But businesses also need a workforce that can afford to live here, find child care and develop the skills employers need. A favorable tax climate means less if companies cannot find the workers they need to grow.

These are the accomplishments I would rather hear legislators brag about.

How much have we reduced property taxes for homeowners? How much easier is it for a young couple to buy their first home? Can a working parent or caregiver find affordable child care? Are our schools receiving the resources they need without forcing towns to continually raise property taxes? Can people struggling with addiction get treatment when they are ready for it?

Those are measures of a successful state, too. Those are the outcomes we should measure alongside every tax cut.

The debate we should be having in Concord isn’t whether taxes should always be higher or always be lower. It should be whether we are getting good value for the taxes we pay and whether our tax policies are helping build the New Hampshire we want to live in.

Sometimes the responsible thing to do is cut a tax. Sometimes the responsible thing to do is invest.

The mistake is pretending that cutting taxes is always the same thing as good government.

A tax cut makes a good headline. Strong schools, affordable housing, accessible child care, reasonable property taxes and effective addiction treatment make a strong state.

And ultimately, that ought to be the standard by which we judge our elected officials.

Submitted by George Bald, former Commissioner of the Department of Resources and Economic Development. Also, early in his career, he worked in executive roles in city government in Somersworth and Rochester.

Comments are closed.