Former Chief Justice MacDonald Won’t Get State or Judicial Pension

Courtesy photo

Former Supreme Court Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald who resigned Sept. 15.

Share this story:

By NANCY WEST, InDepthNH.org

Former Supreme Court Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald – who resigned to settle ethics charges – isn’t eligible for a state pension for his four years as attorney general or for a separate judicial pension for five and a half years there, but he isn’t leaving empty handed.

MacDonald, 64, was paid his regular weekly salary while on medical leave for about seven weeks from July 24 until his resignation on Sept. 15 when the Judicial Conduct Committee announced his violation of three canons of the Code of Judicial Conduct. His annual salary at the time was $208,157.

“While on medical leave, the Chief Justice received his regular paycheck. In his last check, in addition to his regular paycheck, the Chief Justice received $19,539.27, which represents the terminal pay from his positions as Attorney General and Chief Justice of the Supreme Court as provided by RSA 94:9,” said David Sakowich, spokesman for the judicial branch.

Sakowich said that terminal pay includes items such as earned but unused vacation or sick time.

Although MacDonald is not eligible for a pension due to his age and length of service, he is eligible to receive the money he paid into the judicial retirement plan which was 10 percent of his salary that he contributed over the years, according to attorney Charles Douglas, executive director of the New Hampshire Judicial Retirement Plan.

The total amount of MacDonald’s contributions with interest is $112,872.51 as of Sept. 30, 2026, according to Douglas. MacDonald hasn’t asked to withdraw any of that money.

MacDonald, who will turn 65 later this month, hasn’t spoken publicly about his plans since his resignation.

In a statement released the day he resigned, MacDonald said: “I believe this is in the best interest of the New Hampshire Judicial Branch. I accept responsibility and accountability for my conduct,” MacDonald wrote to Gov. Kelly Ayotte in a letter dated Sept. 15. “The resignation is consistent with the terms of the Stipulation and Agreement with the Judicial Conduct Committee dated Sept. 8, 2026,” MacDonald said.

Under the agreement, MacDonald admitted violations of three provisions of the Code of Judicial Conduct and resigned his judicial appointment, including his position as Chief Justice of the New Hampshire Supreme Court, effective immediately.

 On Sept. 8, MacDonald offered to settle and the committee agreed avoiding a public hearing. MacDonald agreed to pay for legal fees incurred by the JCC.

MacDonald admitted that he failed to act in a manner that promotes public confidence, failed to perform duties without partiality related to the employment of Dianne Martin “including bypassing Judicial Branch rules” in extending her a position without a comprehensive, merit-based process required by the court and failed to avoid favoritism, according to the JCC’s Summary report of Proceedings, Findings and Recommendations.

This related to Martin being laid off for three days, being re-hired as bar counsel and receiving a $50,000 payout of accrued vacation and sick time.

The Judicial Conduct Committee summary said it was the New Hampshire Public Radio story by Todd Bookman Oct. 23, 2025 that revealed the unusual Dianne Martin payout, and a public statement by the high court Oct. 31, 2025 that prompted the JCC to investigate.

The joint statement issued on Oct. 31, 2025, by Chief Justice MacDonald and Associate Justices Patrick Donovan, Melissa Countway and Bryan Gould in response to Bookman’s article played a role in the matter. Questions linger as to whether Donovan, Countway, and Gould are now under investigation by the JCC because of their role in the letter.

“Finally, the press release issued by the Court on Oct 31, 2025 under MacDonald’s leadership did not accurately portray the process for Martin’s removal and rehire to a new position. It created the misimpression that her removal and rehire was part of a routine administrative reorganization of the AOC.

“The evidence established that there were long-standing and serious concerns about Martin’s management of the ACO. As a result, the Committee finds that there is clear and convincing evidence that MacDonald violated Cannon 2 Rule 2.3 (A) when he failed to exercise the power of administrative appointment impartially and on the basis of merit, and failed to avoid favoritism, with respect to the personnel decisions related to Dianne Martin,” the JCC summary reads.

MacDonald graduated from Dartmouth College cum laude in 1983 with a bachelor’s degree in government after attending public school in Hanover. From 1985 to 1990, MacDonald worked as legislative director for U.S. Sen. Gordon Humphrey becoming his chief of staff before earning a juris doctorate magna cum laude from Cornell Law school. After working at Nelson, Kinder, Mosseau & Gordon, PC, he became an associate, then a partner in the litigation department of Nixon Peabody in Manchester until he was sworn in as Attorney General in 2017, then became Chief Justice of the Supreme Court in 2021.

Reporter Paula Tracy contributed to this report.


Comments are closed.