By KATHARINE WEBSTER, InDepthNH.org
Members of the state legislature’s incoming Democratic majority plan to file bills repealing or restricting cooperation agreements between ICE and New Hampshire law enforcement agencies.
They also will introduce legislation that would ban the use of electric shock gloves by federal agents, ban the use of electronic surveillance and identification techniques, require ICE agents to respect immigrants’ constitutional rights – and more.
Whether Gov. Kelly Ayotte, a Republican, will sign any of those bills is an open question.
Democrats won a 291-108 super-majority of seats in the House, but fell one vote shy of a veto-proof majority in the Senate, where they will hold a 15-9 majority.
“We have an array of bills,” state Rep. Nicholas Germana, D-Keene and a member of House Democratic leadership, said. “We want to give the governor a set of options on how to rein in ICE.”
After Donald Trump won reelection as president in 2024, Ayotte directed the state police to cooperate with ICE and encouraged local police and county sheriffs to sign cooperation agreements with the agency as well.
In the past two years, the governor also signed bills passed by the majority Republican legislature that banned cities and towns from enacting “sanctuary” policies, required law enforcement agencies to cooperate with ICE, and allowed police and county sheriffs to sign cooperation agreements with ICE without obtaining approval from their local governments.
According to ICE’s website, the Hillsborough, Rockingham and Belknap County sheriff’s offices currently have 287(g) “identify and arrest” agreements with ICE, as do state police and 27 municipal police departments.
The departments receive money and ICE training for some officers, who are deputized to identify, arrest and process immigrants with current or pending criminal charges against them and to participate in task force actions with ICE and other federal agents.
Germana said he hopes that Ayotte will be willing to rethink her past positions, citing polls that show the majority of state residents do not support family separation or the summary arrest and deportation of immigrants and refugees who have no criminal history and are contributing to their communities. That is especially true after the detentions and ICE killings of American citizens and shootings and violent detentions of legal immigrants elsewhere, he said.
“I think the governor is aware that the opinion of the general public is, ‘Yeah, it’s fine to deport those who have violent criminal convictions,’” Germana said. “But last time I checked, more than 80 percent of the people being held in (the federal prison in) Berlin and in Strafford County (jail) had no criminal convictions.”
Ayotte’s spokesperson did not return an email seeking comment on what, if any, of the immigration changes being proposed by the Democrats she would veto or be willing to consider.
Anti-Sanctuary and ICE Cooperation Bills
Rep. Alissandra Murray, D-Manchester, one of two Latinos in the state legislature, says she plans to file a bill that would repeal the ban on so-called “sanctuary communities” with policies such as prohibiting local police and jails not to provide information to ICE without a valid arrest warrant naming a specific individual and signed by a judge, known as a “judicial warrant.”
In May 2025, Lebanon and Hanover were placed on a U.S. Department of Homeland Security list of “sanctuary communities” that obstruct federal immigration enforcement efforts. The list was taken down a few days later.
Michael Garrity, spokesman for the Attorney General’s Office, said that no communities have been prosecuted or punished under the law barring sanctuary cities and towns.
“We have not received any complaints or reports of violations and thus have not conducted any investigations or taken any enforcement actions,” he said in an email.
Murray also plans to file a bill that would repeal the law allowing law enforcement agencies and correctional facilities to make independent agreements with ICE without permission from their local municipal and county governments, “so these agents no longer have free will to terrorize our local communities without any input from local government.”
When police departments and sheriffs work with ICE, it negatively affects the ability of immigrants, refugees and the state’s growing Latino population “to have a healthy and trusting relationship with local law enforcement,” she said.
State Sen. Bill Gannon, R-Sandown, who sponsored some of last year’s main immigration enforcement bills, did not return an email seeking comment. However, law enforcement agencies that cooperate with ICE are not required to report the immigration status of crime victims and witnesses under state law.
Murray is also working on a bill with Rep. Trinidad Tellez, D-Manchester, that would ban federal agents from using electric gloves or wearing face masks when carrying out immigration enforcement operations in New Hampshire. The bill would also require federal agents to wear and use body cameras.
Bills to Restore Local Elected Officials’ Control
State Rep. Albert “Buzz” Scherr, D-Portsmouth, a professor of constitutional law at the University of New Hampshire, said he plans to sponsor bills that would ban the construction of ICE facilities in the state and require every law enforcement and correctional agency to get approval from its local government before signing a cooperation agreement with ICE.
“Right now, the sheriff of Rockingham County thinks he doesn’t need the permission of the county commissioners,” Scherr says. My bill “doesn’t say no law enforcement agency can sign a 287(g) agreement. It says it’s an issue of local control, it’s not an issue of what the police department wants or what the state wants.”
That bill, if it passes, could lead to some fireworks at the county level.
The sheriffs of all three counties that currently have 287(g) agreements – Belknap, Hillsborough and Rockingham – are Republicans who ran unopposed on both the Republican and Democratic sides of the Nov. 3 general election ballot.
But control of the Hillsborough County Commission and the county delegation – all of the state representatives whose districts lie within the county – will soon be firmly in Democratic hands, and the commissioners and delegation could potentially phase out or terminate the agreement.
The Belknap and Rockingham County delegations also will flip to Democratic majorities, but Republicans will keep control of the county commissions.
County delegations are responsible for approving the commission’s proposed budget and for appropriating funds to run the jail, the sheriff’s department and other county offices. That means the Democratic majority delegations could choose to tighten the purse strings, putting pressure on the commissioners and sheriffs to alter policy, Scherr says.
Scherr also is sponsoring a bill that would give New Hampshire residents a “private right of action for constitutional violations by federal actors” – in other words, the right to sue federal agents for violating their constitutional rights.
Restricting ICE Behavior and Regulating 287(g) Agreements
Germana said local control is essential because “law enforcement agencies’ primary responsibility is to the communities they serve,” not the federal government.
“We can’t have unrestricted federal agencies coming in to our communities without identifying what federal agency they’re with or telling us who they took or where they went,” he said.
He plans to file a comprehensive bill modeled on a new law in Virginia that restricts cooperation agreements with ICE, including barring police, sheriff’s deputies and correctional staff from identifying or detaining someone with only a civil immigration violation and no criminal history, absent a valid judicial warrant or subpoena.
“If they (ICE agents) have a warrant for a specific person and they enter into our communities to execute that warrant, that’s fine, but that’s not what’s happening,” Germana said.
Across the country, ICE and Customs and Border Protection have repeatedly used administrative warrants to raid workplaces and homes, forcibly entered the homes of citizens and legal immigrants as well as illegal immigrants, and detained suspected illegal immigrants who were not identified in any warrant, he said.
The Virginia law specifically bars ICE agents and local police from forcibly entering a home unless they have a valid search or arrest warrant signed by a judge.
“Our residents in New Hampshire have the right to live without the fear that they’re going to have an unidentified, unaccountable federal force entering their homes,” said Germana, a professor of history at Keene State College.
“This is for the protection of everybody in our community,” he said. “Whether or not somebody is an American citizen, they have constitutional due process rights, and they should be detained on a judicial warrant, and the Supreme Court has been unequivocal about that.”
The Virginia law bars agencies from participating in 287(g) agreements unless, when ICE plans enforcement actions in the state, it provides local authorities with the names and ranks of all the agents who will be participating a week before any operations.
Agents must be clearly identified as ICE agents during arrests and detentions under the law: They cannot just wear jackets marked “Police.”
The Virginia law also bans ICE operations and raids at schools, courthouses and faith-based organizations, and bars it from carrying out enforcement actions within 500 yards of polling places during elections.
It also bans using mass surveillance technology, including facial recognition and fingerprint scanning programs, drones, cell phone surveillance and databases, license plate readers, digital forensics and other tools to identify or detain immigrants with no criminal convictions on their records.
And by carrying out enforcement operations in the state, ICE agrees that its agents are subject to state laws and can be prosecuted for violating them, including when the agents use force or shoot someone.
“If we do not require the government to act according to the law, and we don’t require the federal government to have search warrants and arrest warrants, it’s everyone’s rights that are ultimately on the line,” Germana said.
The Trump administration has sued to block the Virginia law, and in September a federal judge issued a temporary injunction blocking the parts that apply to federal agents. The judge also said that existing 287(g) “arrest and detain” task force agreements could continue with no changes while the case is being litigated.
However, the judge left in place the requirements for new 287(g) agreements. Given that ICE is opposed to the law’s restrictions, it’s unlikely that Virginia will see any new cooperation agreements.