By PAULA TRACY, InDepthNH.org
CONCORD – House Democratic Leader Alexis Simpson, D-Exeter, is calling on Republican Gov. Kelly Ayotte to hold Attorney General John Formella accountable to a report that he and two senior aides accepted more than $71,000 in travel reimbursements from the Rule of Law Defense Fund, a Republican dark-money group tied to mobilization of individuals ahead of the January 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol.
And the only Democratic Executive Councilor is calling on Formella to answer questions about the Department of Justice’s position on arguing cases to the high court while it is unclear if three of the justices are being investigated by the Judicial Conduct Committee related to the resignation of Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald.
SIMPSON ON FORMELLA
Simpson said according to the InDepthNH.org report here: https://indepthnh.org/2026/10/06/ag-formella-trips-funded-by-group-tied-to-jan-6-riot/, “Our very own Attorney General and his top aides have accepted more than $71,000 in spa and golf resort trips from a dark money group. This same group ran self-described ‘war games’ to prepare for a Trump loss in 2020, then paid for robocalls urging supporters to march on the Capitol on January 6th.
“These actions raise questions about whether Granite Staters can trust Governor Ayotte to stand up to the Trump administration and defend our elections against federal interference. I’m calling on Governor Ayotte to hold her Attorney General accountable and compel him to disclose whether he or his staff have participated in any ‘war games’ in preparation for the 2026 or 2028 elections,” Simpson said.
Ayotte is running for re-election and is being challenged by Democrat Cinde Warmington. Simpson is also running for re-election. Ayotte did not respond to a request for comment.
Simpson was responding to a story published Wednesday in InDepthNH.org https://indepthnh.org/2026/10/06/ag-formella-trips-funded-by-group-tied-to-jan-6-riot/
In the article, Damien Fisher reported that Formella, Department of Justice Communications Director Michael Garrity, and Senior Assistant Attorney General Christopher Bond all went to meetings and conferences on the RLDF dime.
When asked for a response to Simpson’s press release Wednesday, Garrity said only: “In response to the release question about war games here is what we would say, ‘The answer is no.'”
The 501 (c)4, RLDF serves as the public policy arm for RAGA. The partisan RAGA works to elect Republicans to Attorneys General positions. The two groups share staff and the majority of RLDF board members are Republican attorneys general.
According to the Associated Press, a Sept. 24, 2020, email from RAGA and RLDF Executive Director Adam Piper addressed to “Generals,” called the first meeting, a two-day Atlanta, Georgia event, “WAR GAMES” described as a “series of conversations planning for what could come if we lose the White House.”
According to the Associated Press, the executive director of both RLDF and RAGA organized more than 20 “War Game” meetings with Republican attorneys general and their staffers starting in the fall of 2020, before the elections.
“It was a fast paced, productive series of war games, which hopefully will not have to be utilized in November,” Piper said in an email sent the next day, addressed to “Generals,” and obtained by the AP.
On Jan. 6, 2021 a mob stormed the U.S. Capitol building in an attempt to stop Congress from legally certifying Biden’s election.
Piper resigned when it was revealed RLDF deployed a recorded message through robocalls to Trump supporters encouraging them to attend the Jan. 6 rally and to stop Biden’s election.
“Republican Attorneys General Association and Rule of Law Defense Fund had no involvement in the planning, sponsoring, or the organization of [the Jan. 6] event,” a statement by the organization read.
Michael Garrity noted in a response to InDepthNH.org that was included in the original story published Tuesday, that “Attorney General Formella does not condone the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol or actions associated with it, nor does he endorse actions attributed to RLDF related to the Jan. 6 attack. Those events predate his tenure, which began on April 22, 2021. Attorney General Formella believes former President Biden won the 2020 presidential election, just as he believes President Trump won the 2016 and 2024 elections.”
“Attorney General Formella and his staff participate in multiple national Attorney General forums and organizations, including the National Association of Attorneys General (NAAG), the Republican Attorneys General Association (RAGA), and the Attorney General Alliance (AGA). Some are bipartisan, some are Republican, but all provide opportunities for New Hampshire to work with other states and have a voice in national discussions,” Garrity said.
Garrity was reimbursed $17,100 for eight trips since the start of 2023. Bond received $29,950 for 14 RAGA trips reimbursed by RLDF. One of Bond’s RLDF-funded trips, an October, 2025 excursion to the Kiawah Island Golf Resort in South Carolina, is listed as an RLDF staff meeting. Bond was reimbursed $1,500 for making it to that meeting.
Garrity said Tuesday that Bond was not and is not a staffer for RLDF.
Garrity said the conference events attended by New Hampshire officials did benefit New Hampshire and were not all about golf and activities. “No New Hampshire taxpayer dollars were used for these expenses, and the expenses are publicly disclosed,” Garrity said.
In her statement calling for the governor to take action, Simpson noted that this is coming at a time of great turmoil involving the highest levels of government.
New Hampshire Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald resigned September 15 after admitting violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct.
As she noted, InDepthNH.org reported October 1st, a Judicial Conduct Committee investigator also informed Justices Melissa Countway, Patrick Donovan, and Bryan Gould that they “had exposure under the rules.”
The three signed on with MacDonald to a press release calling the laying off of a senior staff and rehiring several days later to be essentially routine restructuring when that staffer received almost $50,000 owed to her while her hiring in a new role was without posting or competition for it.
Democratic legislative leaders have requested public disclosure of whether investigations involving three sitting justices are still pending but have not heard.
Also, in an October 7th Union Leader op-ed titled “Restore trust in New Hampshire’s highest court,” Rep. Nick Germana (D-Keene) called on Countway, Donovan, and Gould to step aside from court duties pending an investigation into their involvement in the conduct case that preceded MacDonald’s resignation.
Germana also raised concerns about Gould’s prior role as Gov. Ayotte’s campaign counsel and attorney Richard Lehmann’s simultaneous representation of Supreme Court justices and the state Senate as its legal counsel.
LIOT HILL SPEAKS OUT
On Wednesday another Democrat, Executive Councilor Karen Liot Hill, D-Lebanon sent a letter to Formella, with copies to the governor and the four other Executive Councilors, asking Formella about “unresolved ethical questions surrounding three sitting members of the New Hampshire Supreme Court.”
“…my concern is not with the outcome of any particular case, nor am I asking your office to determine whether Justices Donovan, Countway, or Gould committed ethical misconduct. That is properly the responsibility of the Judicial Conduct Committee.
“My concern is with the Department of Justice’s own responsibilities as counsel for the State of New Hampshire and as a frequent litigant before the Supreme Court.
“The JCC’s findings regarding former Chief Justice Gordon MacDonald raise serious questions about the conduct of the three sitting justices. Yet we do not know whether the JCC is investigating those justices or whether those questions have otherwise been resolved. Meanwhile, your office continues to appear before the Court and ask these same justices to decide matters on behalf of the State,” Liot Hill said.
“I therefore ask: Do you believe it is in the public interest for the Department of Justice to continue arguing cases before Supreme Court justices who are implicated in potential ethical misconduct arising from the JCC’s findings, while the status of those matters remains unresolved?
“Has the Department considered filing motions seeking the disqualification or recusal of Justices Donovan, Countway, and Gould from cases in which the State is a party until these outstanding questions are resolved? If not, why not? What standard is the Department applying to determine whether the circumstances surrounding these justices create an appearance of impartiality sufficient to warrant seeking their disqualification?
“How can the Department make an informed determination about whether disqualification is warranted when neither litigants nor the public know whether any of these justices are currently subjects of JCC investigations arising from the MacDonald matter?
“These are no longer abstract questions. A criminal defendant has already raised concerns about potential JCC investigations involving members of the Court, and the Supreme Court postponed oral argument in that case. The unresolved uncertainty is now affecting proceedings before the Court,” Liot Hill wrote.
“I respect both the independence of our judiciary and the confidentiality required during judicial-conduct proceedings. But those principles must be balanced against the rights of litigants, the fair administration of justice, and the public’s confidence in our courts.
“The Attorney General has a unique responsibility to represent the interests of the State and its people. I would appreciate a clear explanation of how your office is fulfilling that responsibility while these serious questions about members of our highest court remain unresolved,” Liot Hill’s letter concludes.