By DAMIEN FISHER, InDepthNH.org
Men and women who survived physical and sexual abuse as children at the hands of state employees inside the Sununu Youth Services Center – then called YDC – say the new rules for the YDC Settlement Fund betray their trust all over again, and they are not alone.
Several survivors who stayed their civil lawsuits against the state and opted to undergo the settlement fund process are now suing over the change in law that led to the ouster of Fund Administrators John Broderick and his deputy Judge Diane Nicolosi. This week, New York attorney Deborah Greenspan, who served as a deputy Special Master for the Sept. 11 Victim Compensation Fund, filed an affidavit calling out the state’s conflict of interest.
“I am aware of no relevant circumstances wherein a victim compensation fund, settlement fund, or the like, allows an interested party in the underlying dispute to serve as a settlement administrator aimed at resolving said dispute or to veto the determinations of the settlement administrator,” Greenspan wrote. “Such a construct would go beyond the appearance of impropriety and create a clear conflict of interest, undermining the fairness and legitimacy of the settlement process.”
As survivor Andrew Foley states in an affidavit filed in court, the same system that helped cover up his abuse for decades will now decide what it should pay in compensation.
“As I understand it, the State will now decide for itself how much my claim is worth. That is not a fair process. I should not be surprised by the State’s betrayal. My original instincts were correct — I cannot trust the State to live up to its word,” Foley wrote.
Greenspan is serving as an expert witness for the survivors, represented by Nixon Peabody attorney David Vicinanzo. The victims say the new law, which went into effect July 1, means state employees once again control their fate. More than 1,500 claims from survivors were filed with the Settlement Fund before the June 30 deadline, and before the law changed.
“Only after the ‘vast majority’ of the YDC victims had taken the bait and filed (Settlement Fund) claims, did the State move to unilaterally alter the bargain in fundamental ways … The amendments move the administrator to the executive branch and provide the Governor and the Attorney General with unfettered power to control the administrator’s decision making, effectively destroying the promise of a fair, impartial, and victim-centered claims process. The YDC victims were once again betrayed by the State,” Vicinanzo wrote in a response to the State’s motion to dismiss.
Under the new legal set up, the YDC Fund administrator can be hired or fired by Gov. Kelly Ayotte, and any decisions the administrator or his team make can be overruled by Attorney General John Formella. In one of several victim affidavits filed in Merrimack Superior Court, John Doe 334 expressed dismay that he agreed to settle with the state.
“On behalf of the State, the Attorney General now has the power to accept or reject my award also, again putting me at the mercy of the State,” Doe 334 wrote. “If Attorney General Formella were to exercise his power in my case and reject or diminish the award that Administrator Nicolosi, a fair and impartial party, found to be the fair number to settle my claim with the State … I would then be forced to decide whether to amend my complaint to include the sexual abuse that I would be forced to disclose publicly in open court or, if I am still too traumatized and unable to do so, forego justice entirely. For the State to again have this authority over me undermines the whole point of the Settlement Fund process.”
Greenspan is expected to testify Tuesday in court for a preliminary hearing. Broderick is also being sought as a witness for the survivors.
Correction: The name of the former deputy administrator of the YDC settlement fund is Diane Nicolosi.